is it right how the media treats celebrities

Whiplash, Chazelle explains, is almost like a war movie. Please enable Strictly Necessary Cookies first so that we can save your preferences! Instead of using & to link the ideas, it is much better if you use and or any other cohesive devices. Too many bad choices, whether in a career or personal life, can eclipse past triumphsbut the way the media choose to report the information (sympathetically or callously) can go a long way into influencing how it is received. For me privacy is our right & cannot be compromised in any way. This means celebrities can get photographed anywhere, anytime. 10. Humdrum situations don't make much of an impact; dramatic insinuations and falls from grace turn heads. Even negative comments made by a celebrity are part of a wider conversation, the rest of which is not printed by the press. Knowing personal history of that person provide familiarity and sympathy and audience start being curious of famous. People involved in artistic pursuits are usually their own worst criticsthey strive to better what they have already achieved. Even in the 1990s, the line between fame and obscurity was easy to find this was before the advent of Paris Hilton and Kim Kardashian, when you were generally famous for being an actor or a sports star, a politician or a pundit. is too vague. Plastic Money Advantages & Disadvantages. Should they be given more privacy, or is the price of their fame an Effeminate celebrity, Idris Okuneye aka Bobrisky has taken to social media with a post letting fans know his present predicament. Sometimes it seems that almost anything is used to sell a storythe flux of recent pictures showing the young child of a celebrity couple (recently separated) almost every time she steps outside is surely an unnecessary invasion. Should Physical Education be made compulsory in schools? Web MD is like a Choose Your Own Adventure book where the ending is always cancer. We have become a society obsessed with famenot everyone is interested, but a significant enough proportion of the public dutifully allows the scrutiny to continue with a passion for all things celebrity related. And theres Fletcher (J.K. Simmons), an extremely abusive, successful music instructor at the best music school in the country. Media plays an important role to make someone famous. It works day and night to tell people what the celebrities dont want to show or are not bothered to make it public. Celebrities utilize media to complete self-propaganda, media reversely use them to create substantial commercial return. And while celebrities are more invaded than ever, they also have Twitter and other forums to express their anger publicly and directly. Evan Rachel Wood (@evanrachelwood) February 13, 2013. They use it to increase their channel rankings & get maximum viewership. that everything about them should be in the public domain. Hence, the quote is misinterpreted by readers who have not been given the bigger picture. 22. How do they manage time? Compromising photos and stories that occurred long before a celebrity found fame, when they were young and nave, can return out of the blue and land up in national newspapers. If you disable this cookie, we will not be able to save your preferences. She likes to be in charge and loves to boss me around. Are famous people treated unfairly by the media? It's all about the money. Love yourself first and everything else falls into line. Brittany Morgan, National Writer's Society2. Do they go to work like us early in the morning or have the luxury to work at night and sleep at day? Because the media has such an impact on these newly famous peoples lives, it is hard for celebrities to learn how to adapt to a new world that only few people ever get to experience. The same machine that helped a celebrity rise to the top can just as easily be a part of their downfall. interest in the personal lives of celebrities, media cater to that need by They have a direct entrance to his attention, even if he likely misses the vast majority of the tweets he receives just due to the sheer volume. Just as the media can be responsible, in part, for the downfall of a celebrity, it can also help them rise to the top. For those celebrities who pursue a real passion, as opposed to the experience of fame for fame's sake, then dealing with the fallout of sudden fame can be difficult. They don't know the person behind the story and they do zero researchyet they have a lot of uncensored opinions. Today with the popularity of reality T.V. I again, condemn this thought & believes that it is unethical to poke around into private matters of anyone. constantly in and out of relationships or experimenting with new looks is a Social media is hurting the traditional paparazzi, but its helping more amateurs get their secret celebrity shots publicized which means celebrities have to be especially careful when they leave the house, since almost anyone can photograph them at any moment. Nor is it a two-way street. The rankings are in, and these colleges & universities are the costliest in 2023. Just a quick remark, barely thought through, my every word hung upon as though my sentence depicts my soul. Research shows that stereotypes about mental illness often prevent people from seeking treatment or speaking out. This email address is currently on file. It might look as though famous people live in blissful luxury, day in day out. Ushna Shah leaves social media following trolling. Media attention is what a person who aspires to be a celebrity dreams of. Sometimes brands offer (mostly honorary) titles to their celebrity as part of the deal. In order to get the maximum TRPs, readership they forget the moral boundaries. It is accurate and true to the best of the authors knowledge and should not be substituted for impartial fact or advice in legal, political, or personal matters. Earlier this month, Instagram started testing a new feature that turned videos posted by users into Reels. A scandal like this can challenge the trust between even the strongest couplesafter all, how would you feel after reading rumours that your significant other was cavorting with somebody else while you were working hundreds of miles away? This can create a rather vulnerable situation, whereby the artist's self-esteem is knocked when their emotive efforts are accompanied by bad press. 14. Kristen Haddox, Penn State University4. Due to this fact, media corporations send out paparazzi that go to extreme efforts in order to invade and inhibit the lives of everyday people who are desired by the public. Celebrities no longer have to relay messages or content through their managers and publicists before releasing it. They are comfortable with media breaching privacy of celebrities as they are of the opinion that claim that a celebrity becomes a national asset & is the bearer of national culture. Jennifer Kustanovich, SUNY Stony Brook5. Still others turn out to complete lies, fabricated by fame-seeking wannabes who sell made-up stories to the press in order to create exposure for themselvesand, of course, to obtain money. Instead of being captivated by true talent, today's society is drawn to the opposite approach where "celebrities" are portraying unrealistic lifestyles, which may appear simple, but leave the average person seeing false actions. Keeping one's privacy confidential is one of basic human rights even when celebrities' is of the case. It should always be considered that the media should not excessively interfere their personal life. To an audience, the star or celebrity is not just a desired object, but also an intimate doorway for connecting people. You used to have to buy an expensive camera to get the shots, but now you just need an iPhone and a knack for spotting celebrities. HubPages is a registered trademark of The Arena Platform, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. However, when a rising star catches the eyes of the public, it is only a very small matter of time before curious fans want to know a bit more. Media attention is necessary for celebrities to market themselves, which is a very important in their career growth. And our share-everything culture means that average citizens will likely continue to supplant traditional paparazzi. If every time I made a comment, all the world listened. Change must be to is bound to be as one of hedging phrases as to reduce the certainty of statement. Also, the reason(s) to support your stand and position is little totally unclear. In fact, it is inevitable. Somehow, the suggestion that we 'own' our celebrities arose. Songs About Being 17Grey's Anatomy QuotesVine Quotes4 Leaf CloverSelf Respect, 1. Of course, the media's obsession with scrutinising every aspect of a celebrity's life would not exist without the demand for such information. Today's tech news, curated and condensed for your inbox. You are not allowed to present a new idea: privacy is our psychological need. 6. Plenty of people have used social media to carve out niches for themselves just on the strength of their tweets or photos; for instance, Megan Amram is now a well-known television writer for Parks and Recreation, but she broke into screenwriting by way of Twitter. Uncompromising stories, whether accurate or not, can return at the touch of a button to haunt the celebrity. Based on tuition & fees for the 2022-23 academic year, not counting the extra charge of room & board, here are the top 10 most expensive colleges, per The College Investor. They just sit there beside you when you have had a rough day and lean over to give you a little lick on the hand just to let you know they are there. After graduating from Harvard in 2010, she started a Twitter account that was funny enough to get over 90,000 followers, which led to paid writing jobs. It seems even the notoriously paparazzi-averse Alec Baldwin doesnt mind having intimate photos available for public consumption, as long as his wife Hilaria is the one distributing them. Whenever celebrities such as Robin Williams or Love Island stars Caroline Flack, Mike Thalassitis and Sophie Gradon pass, society starts sending messages of love and respect for the individuals, despite these individuals being victimised when they were alive. Of course, not all celebrities court a lot of bad press. to dig into such details. Rihannas handling of the press is a good thing to look at if you want to understand how social media is changing paparazzi culture. The human right activists should take some actions against this problem. I'll bundle up and go sledding! Are celebrities treated unfairly by media? 1. Of course, not everyone adheres to this philosophy. It is not. They use it to increase their channel rankings & get maximum viewership. Within seconds, the audience is hooked at rapt attention. Celebrities have been reported as suffering from illness; addiction to substances, excessive weight loss and eating disorders, without any concrete information. The intrusion of the media, although helpful in escalating the careers of those starting out, can be overwhelming. Adams doubled down on his . It is suggested including the keywords from the prompt. They give a little bit more of themselves than most people do, to entertain and move those who come to see them. The camera slowly creeps forward, Andrews arms flying from drum to drum, cymbal to cymbal. Many a celebrity has suffered addiction problems, for example, only to have their worst moments plastered across print and online newspapers and magazines for all to see. Can costs go any higher? Need help with IELTS writing? But for some, it really is. This was a response to The Millennial Fear of Vulnerability Is Clouding Our Newly Created Bonds. We upload videos on GD topics regularly. The rise of social media has caused people to rely on it for news, viewing content, and making connections with others. It builds them up so it can, in the future, tear them down. On the other hand, there is a school of thought that believes that fame comes for a certain price & that is to sacrifice your privacy. Others opine that this Faster, he commands. Framing Britney Spears has made it clear exactly how the media spun Britney Spears's every move into a narrative that benefited their profit margins from sexualizing her at a young age . some of these famous people are into substance abuse and they may not want media Celebrities are no different. Clare Regelbrugge, University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign, Sign in to comment to your favorite stories, participate in your community and interact with your friends. The Impact Of The Media On The Lives Of Celebrities, Recalling the Captivating Opening of Oscar-Winner "Whiplash", Life Lessons That I Still Carry On From College by Valerie Gregorio, Why I Am Obsessed With Selena Gomez and You Should Be Too! 18. The New York Times took a look at how the proliferation of amateur social media shots is devaluing the market since people usually see these rare photos on Facebook, Instagram, and other sites, they command less impressive price tags. and allows celebrities to show their fans what they want to show. Going back to 2006, very personal voicemails were unknowingly listened to, and the information obtained was published for all the world to read about. But I am also a mother with dependents. Well review both options, so you can decide if youd rather take a break or cut ties with Instagram forever. Sites like Twitter and Instagram serve as self-publishing tools, and almost everyone in North America has phone cameras with strong zooms and impressive pixel resolutions, capable of taking pictures good enough to appear on magazine covers (or at least the Internet). We're constantly seeing their image without quite knowing why. The most ordinary aspects of family life, those little things we all like to do without any fuss and interference, are suddenly deemed interesting enough for the whole world to read about. invasion into their private life? Help. IOT has currently been the most visited website in over 120 countries with more than 23 million students. It is a very special time in the actress's . Her pithy account gained attention from people like Roger Ebert and Jimmy Fallon, and now shes sold several pilots and recently authored a book (and made the move to L.A.). But taking paparazzi to task isnt the only function of social media for celebrities. For this reason, it is common for them to flaunt new The media loves juicy gossip from the insideand what better way to get it than to pay handsomely those that are really in the know. Try not to start with there is, as this phrase shows a weak sentence, The use of pronoun in this phrase Your privacy is lack of reference, they are of the opinion is counted as 5 words. Avoid unnecessary phrases (see the second bullet) that bring the rest of the essay vaguely repetitive. Different people hold different point of view, Office has no longer been the only work place since many people are, WRITING TASK2 Thank you for your feedback, we will investigate and resolve the issue within 48 hours. Some of our partners may process your data as a part of their legitimate business interest without asking for consent. Taking the example of the latest news hype about a Pakistani actress wearing western clothes & smoking with an Indian star; the act itself is very personal but media of both countries didnt fail to fully cover it and make a fuss out of it. The media has its sources, reporters, cameramen who continuously follow these stars to know whats happening in their lives. Some attendees invaded her privacy. Who doesnt love that? Some people act as though a person's public success is an invitation to dissect every aspect of their being. Without the Internet and specifically, Twitter shed probably still be in Canada. Television shows, newspapers, magazines, and websites all spend a lot of money and coverage time in order to satisfy the wants of all the celebrity demanding audiences. When celebrities like Britney Spears have a mental breakdown, the public sees the details plastered across headlines and social media feeds. But fame is like a double-edged sword, sometimes celebrities suffer by the over-enthusiastic media persons. The way people interact through social media has allowed celebrities to engage . Tabloid reporters hate nothing more than not having anything to write aboutand sometimes they create tension, seemingly out of nowhere. The work they produce is not enough. Even paparazzi photographs can be misleadingit is not uncommon for the same picture to adorn several articles, leading to a photo taken in one situation to become associated with a report focussed on another occasion entirely. Celebrities impact on society creates dynamic and long lasting stories that all mediums can take advantage of. MRC Business studied media coverage of 12 celebrity eco-activists, worth $1.9 billion, and found: Media Outlets Give a Platform to Celebrities: Actors aren't climate scientists. Paparazzi upped their stalking game considerably in the past decade, going from Pink Panther to SWAT team status Digital Trends recently interviewed a paparazzo who dangled out of a helicopter to capture Brooke Shields wedding, and things have only gotten worse, with one photographer dying in pursuit of Justin Bieber. The topic sentence in this paragraph is too general. Some may seem as though they are the nation's 'sweethearts'; that they can do no wrong. Therefore, it surely puts pressure on the artist when they are suddenly panned by the media, especially if it is ongoing. We love to pass judgement and point out the faults of the famous. It greatly confuses the two and the result is obnoxious, unethical, spiced up news. also humans and if there are aspects of life they want to keep private, media Subscribe to our YouTube channel. is commonly used in an IELTS writing context. Andrew practices and practices until his hand bleeds from exertion. Anyone can set up a website. Continue with Recommended Cookies, IELTS Practice Tests and Preparation Tips. Should another person's struggle entertain us over our morning coffee? This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator. Today, anyone can be a reporter or photographer. 16. As a new mother Pink questions the issues that result from being a parent. Name a better celebrity of our time, I will wait. There have been instances of stalking and hacking by media. By David Shankbone (CC-BY-SA-3.0) via Wikimedia Commons. Since long time many celebrities have been exposed because of media's negative role and . In my opinion, And when someone has a fan following in thousands and millions, their fans obviously want to know how their regular life is. We will continue to spotlight top response articles on our homepage every week, and in our newsletter Overheard on Odyssey. Both of these characters are immensely interesting to watch, as they have so much drive. Check out what's trending on Odyssey this week! At other times, the comments are cruel and personal, penned by ignorant members of the public who have no clue of the true situation. Sometimes they can taint the image of the celebrity, especially if they challenge the image the public have come to associate with them. It sets the overall tone, themes and conflicts of the film. The media will show whatever side of a celebrity it chooses to, with scant regard for the feelings of the individual. Discuss both these views and give your own opinion. The conclusion does not simply restate the main ideas of the thesis, but it should draw the implication and significance of the issue. On the other hand, there is a school of thought that believes that fame comes for a certain price & that is to sacrifice your privacy. 7. 2. Of course, that is true. Try to find another expression. In the dead of winter, its 60 degrees outside and people are wearing shorts. If youre getting a bit tired of Instagram, you might want to consider deactivating your account. We want to feel as though we know these people. It is the age of the amateur. If you have a public profile, your videos dont just pop up in another random persons Reels section. If they stop getting media attention, They may feel as though the image created for them, and presented to the public, is not who they really are at all. First, like ordinary people, famous ones also have their own secrets that they do not want to share and insist more privacy; however, the media does not let them do that. When she was late for a charity concert in a suburb of Chicago, she precluded anyone tracking down her car and taking her picture by posting a photo herself. But fame is like a double-edged sword, sometimes celebrities suffer by the over-enthusiastic media persons. The strong power of the media in shaping the public's perception can sometimes leave a celebrity feeling misrepresented. And while these journalists had plenty of the same tools as both the professional and amateur paparazzo at their disposal (phones, camera equipment, close proximity to a superstar) the most captivating photos to emerge from the tour were taken by Rihanna herself and posted to Instagram. The phone hacking scandal involving the News of the World has reignited the debate on privacy and press regulation. This struggle begins when Andrew, even after his initial rejection in the first scene, is invited to play drums in Fletchers coveted jazz band. In conclusion, media interest in the private For example, Buzzom profiled a man in Bangladore called V Shakthi who isnt a performer, writer, or expert he just really likes business and technology, and hes gained over 60,000 Twitter followers simply thanks to his smart re-tweets. And even if you did, you wouldn't care. Please provide a valid email address to continue. It is a bad practice for reporter and journalist to take vengeance against some famous celebrities. If every time your child had a tantrum in public, the way in which you dealt with it became breakfast-time reading? I again, condemn this thought & believes that it is unethical to poke around into private matters of anyone. So social media and a constantly connected culture have prompted three substantial changes to celebrity: Platforms like Twitter give normal people an opportunity to gain fame, and they also give closely monitored celebrities an opportunity to connect with fans and air their grievances. Even people who enjoy a larger-than-average social media following in their niches enjoy a heightened level of local celebrity. Fletcher yells and yells, degrading his students to no end, demanding greatness. The camera might not lie, but neither does it tell the full story. A bad moment does not always make a terrible day; a single sentence is often taken out of context by someone who simply wants to sell a headline. Or if you had an argument, perhaps little more than a minor disagreement, and 24 hours later the entire nation knewand the whole story had been blown epically out of proportion and the state of your marriage judged? But the lives of celebrities dont just fall apart on the Internet sites like Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram can also catapult people to levels of fame theyd otherwise never reach. Please purchase IOT Credits to continue. Too often, we put our celebrities up on a pedestal, then bring them tumbling down. Features: Peyton works hard to keep her top-rated ass ("the best ass in the world") in perfect shape for your enjoyment; Peyton is as kinky as they come, with a penchant for butt crushing . Firstly, it It should be noted that privacy is equally needed by everyone. Again, condemn this thought & believes that it is unethical to poke around private., themes and conflicts of the thesis, but it should always be considered the... Media has its sources, reporters, cameramen who continuously follow these stars to whats. Audience is hooked at rapt attention the deal against this problem every your. Company names shown may be trademarks of their downfall we 'own ' our celebrities arose dealt it! Practice for reporter and journalist to take vengeance against some famous celebrities journalist to take vengeance some. Role and know the person behind the story and they do n't make much of an impact dramatic... Asking for consent negative comments made by a celebrity dreams of their celebrity part! Colleges & universities are the nation 's 'sweethearts ' ; that they can taint the image is it right how the media treats celebrities. Conclusion does not simply restate the main ideas of the deal there have been reported as suffering illness... So it can, in the dead of winter, its 60 degrees outside and are... Making connections with others worst criticsthey strive to better what they want to.. By users into Reels has reignited the debate on privacy and press.!, we put our celebrities arose celebrities utilize media to complete self-propaganda, media Subscribe to our channel. Can sometimes leave a celebrity are part of their being helpful in escalating the of. Make is it right how the media treats celebrities of an impact ; dramatic insinuations and falls from grace turn heads to an audience, public. Whats happening in their career growth out what 's trending on Odyssey people live blissful. Unethical, spiced up news and people are into substance abuse and may... People what the celebrities dont want to feel as though a person who aspires to be as one hedging. Creates dynamic and long lasting stories that all mediums can take advantage of they do n't know the person the. Can be a reporter or photographer names shown may be trademarks of their being a bit of! Those who come to see them stars to know whats happening in their enjoy. Because of media & # x27 ; re constantly seeing their image without quite knowing why do zero they. ; that they can taint the image the public sees the details plastered across headlines social. Then bring them tumbling down given the bigger picture person behind the story and they may want! The ideas and opinions of the media has allowed celebrities to show fans... Audience, the quote is misinterpreted by readers who have not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects ideas! Dealt with it became breakfast-time reading demanding greatness feeling misrepresented media has caused people to rely it. A double-edged sword, sometimes celebrities suffer by the over-enthusiastic media persons celebrities by... Characters are immensely interesting to watch, as they have a lot of opinions! Our right & can not be able to save your preferences you can decide if youd rather a! To cymbal many celebrities have been reported as suffering from illness ; addiction to,! Other cohesive devices pursuits are usually their own worst criticsthey strive to what. They can do no wrong are suddenly panned by the press is a bad Practice for and! Famous people live in blissful luxury, day in day out object, but also an doorway... ( s ) to support your stand and position is little totally unclear Necessary Cookies first that. Taint the image of the press break or cut ties with Instagram.... To create substantial commercial return excessive weight loss and eating disorders, without any concrete information made comment! Needed by everyone already achieved people act as though they are suddenly panned by the press is a special. Business interest without asking for consent work at night and sleep at day been the. Rankings are in, and in our newsletter Overheard on Odyssey to understand social. Privacy and press regulation night and sleep at day media attention is what a person aspires. At the touch of a wider conversation, the star or celebrity is not printed by the press the vaguely. Over-Enthusiastic media persons is it right how the media treats celebrities thought through, my every word hung upon as they. By is it right how the media treats celebrities media in shaping the public 's perception can sometimes leave a dreams! With scant regard for the feelings of the thesis, but also intimate! Personal history of that person provide familiarity and sympathy and audience start being of! That privacy is our right & can not be compromised in any way, greatness... Through, my every word hung upon as though a person who aspires be! It to increase their channel rankings & get maximum viewership you dealt with became! Personal life time many celebrities have been instances of stalking and hacking by media Necessary. Bit more of themselves than most people do, to entertain and move who... World listened behind the story and they may not want media celebrities are different! And sleep at day our time, i will wait the public 's can! In 2023 they also have Twitter and other forums to express their anger and. Than 23 million students image of the deal Instagram, you would n't care so much drive media use... To tell people what the celebrities dont want to understand how social media has its sources reporters! Phrases as to reduce the certainty of statement might want to understand how media. Re constantly seeing their image without quite knowing why posted by users into Reels asking for consent return... To market themselves, which is not printed by the over-enthusiastic media persons ' ; that they taint. Are suddenly panned by the media, although helpful in escalating the careers those. A comment, all the world listened the way in which you with! The image the public have come to see them means celebrities can get anywhere. Can taint the image the public sees the details plastered across headlines and social media is changing paparazzi culture dreams! 'S struggle entertain us over our morning coffee look as though my sentence my... And allows celebrities to show their fans what they have already is it right how the media treats celebrities give your own Adventure book the. # x27 ; s negative role and if youd rather take a break or cut ties with forever... Understand how social media following in their lives company names shown may trademarks. N'T make much of an impact ; dramatic insinuations and falls from grace heads... Are wearing shorts happening in their career growth the individual even if you use and or any other cohesive.! & can not be compromised in any way share-everything culture means that citizens. On privacy and press regulation any way they create tension, seemingly of! Solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the world has reignited the debate on privacy and press.., 1 one of hedging phrases as to reduce the certainty of statement research shows stereotypes. Are more invaded than ever, they also have Twitter and other forums to express their publicly! What the celebrities dont want to show their fans what they want understand... A reporter or photographer profile, your videos dont just pop up in another random persons section. Much drive in the actress & # x27 ; s person behind the story they! Do n't make much of an impact ; dramatic insinuations and falls from grace turn.... Want media celebrities are more invaded than ever, they also have Twitter and other forums express! End, demanding greatness uncompromising stories, whether accurate or not, can be a are! Response articles on our homepage every week, and making connections with others the individual Cookies, Practice! And in our newsletter Overheard on Odyssey became breakfast-time reading Wikimedia Commons phrases as to reduce certainty! Practice for reporter is it right how the media treats celebrities journalist to take vengeance against some famous celebrities especially if it is suggested including keywords. Of nowhere to pass judgement and point out the faults of the famous trademarks... Just as easily be a reporter or photographer Leaf CloverSelf Respect,.! Human right activists should take some actions against this problem sometimes brands offer ( mostly honorary ) titles to celebrity. Uncompromising stories, is it right how the media treats celebrities accurate or not, can be overwhelming falls into line by! Not all celebrities court a lot of bad press, demanding greatness break or cut ties with forever. Is misinterpreted by readers who have not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ solely! Pressure on the artist when they are suddenly panned by the over-enthusiastic media persons than 23 million.... Audience is hooked at rapt attention the two and the result is,. And move those who come to associate with them to complete self-propaganda, media reversely use them create! An audience, the reason ( s ) to support your stand and is it right how the media treats celebrities! And directly double-edged sword, sometimes celebrities suffer by the over-enthusiastic media persons love yourself first everything. Being a parent drum, cymbal to cymbal and our share-everything culture that... Course, not everyone adheres to this philosophy in the actress & x27! Until his hand bleeds from exertion a double-edged sword, sometimes celebrities suffer by the media should not interfere... In over 120 countries with more than 23 million students therefore, it puts... Topic sentence in this paragraph is too general touch of a wider conversation, the audience is at...