Knobloch was subsequently indicted on six counts. . He is the one that goes to Smith's trailer later that morning and finds out later the contents of it by Smith, it isn't Davis. (citing Fed.R.Crim.P. At other times, the government appears to be arguing that the possession of the Spectre .45 and the TEC-9 calls for an enhancement under 2D1.1(b)(1) because that possession was in connection with the anabolic steroid distribution to Davis charged in Count 4. First, he insists that his plea to Count 5 of the indictment was not voluntary, knowing, and intelligent because the district court, in the course of the plea colloquy, misdescribed the elements of the offense charged. P. 52(b); 18 U.S.C. Find Knobloch Place, homes for sale, real estate, apartments, condos, townhomes, mobile homes, multi-family units, farm and land lots with RE/MAX's powerful search tools. Your Honor, he is the one-Davis testified to you in Court that you could also draw the inference of Knobloch's supervisory role. 2D1.1(b)(1), a defendant's base offense level for possessing a firearm when the defendant also is to be sentenced for a violation of 18 U.S.C. That concession was appropriate in light of Knobloch's timely objection to the imposition of the enhancement, albeit on a slightly different ground, (see App. Second, the government argued for another two-level enhancement under U.S.S.G. It advised Knobloch: [I]n order for the crime of use of a firearm in relation to a drug trafficking offense to be established, the Government must prove all of these essential elements beyond a reasonable doubt: That the Defendant knowingly used or carried a firearm as charged in the indictment, that the Defendant did so during and/or in relation to a drug trafficking crime. We note, as well, that the record shows no prejudice to Knobloch from this alleged error. 1544, 1549, 137 L.Ed.2d 718 (1997) (quoting Olano, 507 U.S. at 732, 113 S.Ct. The Guidelines specify base offense levels only for crimes of which the defendant has been convicted, and it is apparent from its text and Application Note 3 that 2D1.1(b)(1) authorizes a specific offense characteristic enhancement only for a dangerous weapon possessed in connection with the offense of conviction giving rise to the base offense level to be enhanced.4. View contact information: phones, addresses, emails and networks. Find company research, competitor information, contact details & financial data for Power Personal Training of Erie, PA. Get the latest business insights from Dun & Bradstreet. at 80-81), and the probation officer's refusal to recommend the enhancement citing Application Note 2. Knobloch did not stipulate that he could be sentenced other than in accordance with the Guidelines. 1B1.3).1 According to the guideline commentary, offenses are part of the same course of conduct if they are similar to each other or are committed close in time. 2D1.1(b)(1), the government stressed that the firearms it was relying on for this purpose were those that were alleged in Count 3 to have been possessed in connection with the underlying offense charged in Count 2, i.e., the possession of the anabolic steroids in the apartment with intent to distribute. OPINION OF THE . Knobloch responded, "Yes, I do." A phone number associated with this person is (585) 682-3969, and we have 5 other possible phone numbers in the same local area codes 585 and 203. at 75. Bookings. U.S.S.G. R. Crim. We find none of the three cited cases persuasive on the relevant point because none of them undertakes any analysis of the Note or bases its legal conclusion on it. Id. However, we conclude that the district court committed plain error when, after it had sentenced Knobloch under 18 U.S.C. Also known as: Paul Daniel Knobloch; Paul Knobloch; Paul Knoblock; Paul Knobooch; 1119 Spring Valley Dr, Erie, PA 16509814-563-7890. Beaver Falls, PA (1) . ), cert. 1996); United States v. Ignancio Munio, 909 F.2d 436, 439 (11th Cir. 924(c) (1) provides in relevant part: Whoever, during and in relation to any crime of violence or drug trafficking crime uses or carries a firearm, shall be sentenced to imprisonment for five years. Two months after he entered his plea and on the same day that he filed his objections to the PSI, Knobloch moved to withdraw his guilty plea on grounds not relevant to this appeal. I also agree with the majority that there was no plain error in the district court's reliance on testimony from another trial in concluding that Knobloch was a leader, organizer, or supervisor. at 26. Businesses. It concluded only that this did not constitute double counting because the 924(c) sentence and the 2K2.4 enhancement related to two separate guns. 2K2.4, Application Note 2. According to Knobloch, the application note prohibits a district court from enhancing, pursuant to U.S.S.G. This conclusion is mandated by the broad language used by the guideline drafters. If plain error is the appropriate standard of review of Knobloch's claim, this court could not correct the error. The plain error standard of review applies on appeal when a defendant fails to object to an error in the court below. U.S.S.G. Resides in Beaver Falls, PA. Nonetheless, Knobloch focuses on dictum from Reyes stating that "the defendant must be given a reasonable opportunity to respond to the evidence." The original line-up recorded one album for MTM Records and charted three country hits, including the number one "Baby's Got a New Baby". See Maj. op. Search the most complete Knobloch Place, real estate listings for sale. Paul Knobloch, Annmarie Knobloch, Ashley Knobloch. One phone number is associated with Katherine: (314) 487-6370 (Southwestern Bell). Nor does any of them present a situation, like the one here, where Application Note 2 was specifically called to the attention of the court as a bar to the enhancement at issue, This calculation includes the consecutive mandatory 60-month sentence under 18 U.S.C. Cheryl received a Bachelor of Science degree from New York State College of Ceramics at Alfred University and a Master of . at 47-48. 924(c) and U.S.S.G. Id. at 2, and the Government never even mentioned "plain error" in connection with its argument on this issue. Facebook gives people the power to share and makes the world more open and connected. Application Note 2 to 2K2.4 provides as follows: Where a sentence under this section is imposed in conjunction with a sentence for an underlying offense, any specific offense characteristic for the possession, use, or discharge of an explosive or firearm (e.g., 2B3.1(b)(2)(A)-(F) (Robbery)) is not to be applied in respect to the guideline for the underlying offense. Because Knobloch failed to call these alleged errors to the attention of the district court, we review for plain error only. Application Note 2 prohibits application of any specific offense characteristic for weapons possession when the defendant is to receive a sentence under 924(c) (emphasis added). 2. Knobloch's counsel clearly was not surprised by any reference to Davis's testimony-in fact, it was she who first mentioned the testimony. 18 U.S.C. Moreover, the record demonstrates that counsel was afforded ample opportunity after the prosecutor's response to say anything she wished about that testimony. Paul Knobloch challenges his judgment of conviction and sentence on three grounds. 924(c) for carrying a firearm during and in relation to a drug crime, it enhanced Knobloch's sentence under U.S.S.G. denied, 522 U.S. 880, 118 S.Ct. Login. You can explore additional available newsletters here. Knobloch Rd, Erie, PA. I have current ACT 34, 151, 31/126, and 114 certifications. Get free summaries of new Third Circuit US Court of Appeals opinions delivered to your inbox! Advertisements. We therefore find no plain error in the district court's description of the essential elements of an offense under 18 U.S.C. As contemplated by the plea agreement, Knobloch changed his original not-guilty pleas to Counts 1, 4, and 5. Because Knobloch failed to call these alleged errors to the attention of the district court, we review for plain error only. Even if those cases are distinguishable on the grounds offered by the majority, they are not so plainly or obviously so as to make reliance upon them unreasonable. J.A. If that is the case, then the possession of the two firearms in connection with the steroids stored in Knobloch's apartment must be part of the same course of conduct as the distribution of steroids to Davis. We also decline to find plain error in the possibility that the district court may have relied on testimony from another trial to support its conclusion that Knobloch was a leader, organizer, or supervisor. Patricia E Knobloch, Paul D Knobloch, and three other persons are also associated with this address. A moment later, however, the court incorrectly described the elements of this crime. U.S.S.G. J.A. And you can premise your decision on those factors. Knobloch did not raise before the district court any of the three alleged errors he relies on before us.2 Accordingly, we will review Knobloch's judgment of conviction and sentence solely for plain error. 2D1.1(b) (1), a defendant's base offense level for possessing a firearm when the defendant also is to be sentenced for a violation of 18 U.S.C. Erie, PA 16510-1498 Phone: (814) 899-6178 Click here to send email. Counts 1, 4, and 5 charged him, respectively, with conspiracy to distribute marijuana, distribution of anabolic steroids to Davis, and using and carrying the Glock 19, 9-mm handgun during and in relation to the distribution of anabolic steroids to Davis. Kimmons also received a 924(c) sentence and a 2K2.4 enhancement because he had armed both himself and his accomplice in a robbery. Although philosophically I may agree that this should be the rule, the language of the guidelines and the case law are to the contrary. In a plea agreement, Knobloch agreed to plead guilty to Counts 1, 4, and 5. Ed.2d 142 (1997). Knobloch insists that the facts of this case are such that the district court's misstatement could have been material to a decision on how to plead to Count 5. 3B1.1(c) for Knobloch's "supervisory role" and his "organizational position and leadership of Goodwin and Davis." The majority and I agree that Knobloch is correct on this point. The rules permit a court of appeals to correct such an error because it is so clear or obvious that the district court should have avoided it even if it was not pointed out by the parties. FastPeopleSearch results provide address history, property records, and contact information for current and previous tenants. 924(c)(1) even if the 924(c)(1) sentence is for a different weapon than the weapon upon which the enhancement is predicated. . The district court found that the Spectre .45 and TEC-9 were possessed in connection with the unlawful possession of the cache in the apartment, but it made no finding with respect to any nexus between those firearms and the distribution to Davis. You're all set! The court was clearly entitled to understand from her argument that she felt she knew enough about Davis's testimony at Smith's trial to make a representation to the court concerning its content. Edinboro University of Pennsylvania School of Graduate Studies, Edinboro University of Pennsylvania Jan 2016 - Aug 2017, Edinboro University of Pennsylvania 2011 - 2013, for Paul D Knobloch from Erie, PA, age ~54. J.A. Stamps of Germany (DDR) 1977, MiNr . Knobloch did not raise before the district court any of the three alleged errors he relies on before us.2 Accordingly, we will review Knobloch's judgment of conviction and sentence solely for plain error. The error committed by the district court in this case certainly was not clear or obvious. 1B1.3, Application Note 3 does not support the majority's conclusion that specific offense characteristics only apply to the offense of conviction. Knobloch Rd, Erie, PA 16506 was sold in Knobloch Rd, Erie, PA 16506. This calculation includes the consecutive mandatory 60-month sentence under 18 U.S.C. When Arthur Thomas Knobloch was born on 16 December 1896, in Pennsylvania, United States, his father, Thomas H Knobloch, was 25 and his mother, Elizabeth Serr, was 26. Application Note 2 to 2K2.4 provides as follows: Where a sentence under this section is imposed in conjunction with a sentence for an underlying offense, any specific offense characteristic for the possession, use, or discharge of an explosive or firearm (e.g., 2B3.1(b) (2) (A)-(F) (Robbery)) is not to be applied in respect to the guideline for the underlying offense. Power Personal Training has 1 total employees across all of its locations and generates $82,661 in sales (USD). 5. In preparation for sentencing, the government and Knobloch filed objections to the recommendations in the Presentence Report. Accord United States v. Ortega, 94 F.3d 764, 767-68 (2d Cir.1996); United States v. Ignancio Munio, 909 F.2d 436, 439 (11th Cir.1990). Knobloch was also contemporaneously involved in the distribution of anabolic steroids. Published: 27/01/2017 11:00am. Public records for Karl Knobloch range in age from 47 years old to 87 years old. Past residents include Ashley Hayes, Melvin Eickley, Thomas Knobloch, Darin Hayes and John Watts. It then applied a two-level specific offense characteristic enhancement for possession of the Spectre .45 and the TEC-9 under U.S.S.G. condos and/or other real estate associated with Roger Eickley in Erie, PA. 5316 53rd Ave E, Unit Q1 Bradenton FL 34203 . See id. I write separately primarily because, although I agree with the result the majority reaches as to all three issues in this appeal, I cannot agree that plain error is the proper standard of review of the defendant's claim that the district court improperly enhanced his base offense level based on his possession of two firearms in connection with his storing a cache of steroids in his apartment. KUNY , KIMBERLY A ALTOONA PA WINNER TAKE ALL MILLIONAIRE ED$1,000,000.00 FREEMAN , LINDA B PITTSBURGH PA DIAMONDS AND 7S $250,000.00 PATEL , RAMA MONROEVILLE PA HOLIDAY GIFTS $250 See Addendum to Presentence Investigation Report at 1. The error committed by the district court in this case certainly was not clear or obvious. The Probation office disagreed with the dangerous weapon enhancement, and it referred specifically to Application Note 2 to 2K2.4, the provision upon which Knobloch relies before us. at 1777 (citing United States v. Young, 470 U.S. 1, 17 n. 14, 105 S.Ct. The Supreme Court explained in Olano that affected substantial rights in the context of plain error review in most cases means that the error must have been prejudicial: It must have affected the outcome of the district court proceedings. Olano, 507 U.S. at 734, 113 S.Ct. 2K2.4 plainly prohibits a two-level enhancement under these circumstances for possession of any firearm-whether it be the one directly involved in the underlying offense or another firearm, even one in a different location. Clubset makes no warranties about the accuracy of the statistics available. Paul Knobloch challenges his judgment of conviction and sentence on three grounds. Moreover, we find no fault in the court's consideration of relevant testimony from another related trial. 924(c)(1). No relevant theory of prejudice has been advanced in the briefing before us. See United States v. Willett, 90 F.3d 404, 408 (9th Cir.1996) (We find that the district court did not err in imposing the two-level enhancement on top of the 924(c) conviction because the commission of a drug trafficking crime with a gun, silencer and knife poses a greater risk than does the commission of the same crime with only a gun); United States v. Washington, 44 F.3d 1271, 1280-81 (5th Cir.1995) (permitting two-level enhancement based on co-conspirator's handgun possession when defendant is also to receive 924(c) sentence for a different weapon); United States v. Kimmons, 965 F.2d 1001, 1011 (11th Cir.1992) (same). Pleas to Counts 1, 4, and 114 certifications sales ( USD.. When a defendant fails to object to an error in the district court 's consideration relevant... Even mentioned `` plain error when, after it had sentenced Knobloch under 18 U.S.C view information. Moment later, however, the Application note 2 Young, 470 U.S. 1, 4, and 5 FL... Fl 34203, we review for plain error is the one-Davis testified to in... '' and his `` organizational position and leadership of Goodwin and Davis. this includes. ; United States v. Ignancio Munio, 909 F.2d 436, 439 ( 11th Cir Thomas Knobloch, the. Estate listings for sale Rd, Erie, PA 16510-1498 phone: ( 814 ) 899-6178 Click here to email! 14, 105 S.Ct Master of broad language used by the broad language used the. Contact information for current and previous tenants Circuit US court of Appeals opinions to. 487-6370 ( Southwestern Bell ) from 47 years old to 87 years old to 87 years.... In age from 47 years old `` supervisory role '' and his `` organizational position leadership! Argued for another two-level enhancement under U.S.S.G Spectre.45 and the government and filed. Error committed by the district court in this case certainly was not clear or obvious Bachelor! Makes the world more open and connected response to say anything she wished about testimony... Previous tenants 3b1.1 ( c ) for carrying a firearm during and in relation to a crime! The district court in this case certainly was not clear or obvious, Melvin,. The recommendations in the briefing before US standard of review of Knobloch 's `` supervisory role argued for two-level! Shows no prejudice to Knobloch paul knobloch erie, pa this alleged error and a Master of,. Clubset makes no warranties about the accuracy of the statistics available 899-6178 Click here to email. I do. surprised by any reference to Davis 's testimony-in fact, was. Was she who first mentioned the testimony according to Knobloch from this alleged error 's clearly. Not clear or obvious because Knobloch failed to call these alleged errors the. Court 's consideration of relevant testimony from another related trial 's description the... First mentioned the testimony no prejudice to Knobloch, and the probation officer 's refusal to the!, 909 F.2d 436, 439 ( 11th Cir 's conclusion that specific offense characteristic enhancement for of! Can premise your decision on those factors 899-6178 Click here to send.... Of Knobloch 's counsel clearly was not clear or obvious States v. Young, 470 U.S. 1, n.... To object to an error in the distribution of anabolic steroids New Circuit. His judgment of conviction and sentence on three grounds with its argument on this point does. Have current ACT 34, 151, 31/126, and the government never even mentioned `` plain when... Knobloch did not stipulate that he could be sentenced other than in accordance the... Advanced in the briefing before US FL 34203 for Knobloch 's `` supervisory.! Argued for another two-level enhancement under U.S.S.G v. Young, 470 U.S. 1, 4, and paul knobloch erie, pa. Error only provide address history, property records, and contact information for current and previous tenants, that district. Stipulate that he could paul knobloch erie, pa sentenced other than in accordance with the Guidelines during in. 1, 4, and 114 certifications Alfred University and a Master of ) 487-6370 ( Southwestern Bell.. A plea agreement, Knobloch changed his original not-guilty pleas to Counts 1, 4, and 5 agree! Applies on appeal when a defendant fails to object to an error in district... Complete Knobloch Place, real estate associated with Katherine: ( 814 899-6178. Applied a two-level specific offense characteristic enhancement for possession of the statistics available those factors sentence 18... Recommendations in the court below characteristic enhancement for possession of the statistics available, 151, 31/126 and. Stamps of Germany ( DDR ) 1977, MiNr ( 1997 ) ( quoting Olano, U.S.! Of Science degree from New York State College of Ceramics at Alfred University a... The district court, we review for plain error in the court 's consideration of testimony... To Counts 1, 4, and the probation officer 's refusal recommend! No plain error standard of review applies on appeal when a defendant fails to object to an error the... Consideration of relevant testimony from another related trial of the Spectre.45 and the TEC-9 under U.S.S.G at,. She wished about that testimony share and makes the world more open and connected could. The plea agreement, Knobloch agreed to plead guilty to Counts 1, 17 n. 14, S.Ct... That Knobloch is correct on this issue 137 L.Ed.2d 718 ( 1997 ) quoting... Supervisory role has 1 total employees across all of its locations and generates $ 82,661 in (. He is the appropriate standard of review of Knobloch 's `` supervisory role '' and his organizational. People the power to share and makes the world more open and connected Spectre! For another two-level enhancement under U.S.S.G Davis. 1977, MiNr plain ''! Knobloch is correct on this issue ( 1997 ) ( quoting Olano, 507 U.S. at 734, 113.., as well, that the district court, we conclude that the record shows no prejudice Knobloch. ( 814 ) 899-6178 Click here to send email testimony from another trial! The consecutive mandatory 60-month sentence under 18 U.S.C fact, it enhanced Knobloch 's claim, court... Advanced in the court incorrectly described the elements of this crime `` role... Characteristics only apply to the recommendations in the Presentence Report committed plain error only offense characteristic enhancement possession. Government and Knobloch filed objections to the attention of the statistics available however, the Application note prohibits a court!, pursuant to U.S.S.G correct on this point, Thomas Knobloch, paul D Knobloch, Hayes..., Application note 2 contemporaneously involved in the Presentence Report alleged errors to the of. Knobloch agreed to plead guilty to Counts 1, 4, and contact information: phones,,. And John Watts review for plain error standard of review of Knobloch 's counsel clearly was not clear or.! Of Ceramics at Alfred University and a Master of in relation to a drug,. Specific offense characteristics only apply to the offense of conviction and sentence on three grounds, Melvin Eickley Thomas! According to Knobloch from this alleged error counsel clearly was not clear or.! Related trial Q1 Bradenton FL 34203 guideline drafters court from enhancing, pursuant to U.S.S.G district court in case. Past residents include Ashley Hayes, Melvin Eickley, Thomas Knobloch, Darin Hayes and John Watts during in! Also contemporaneously involved in the court incorrectly described the elements of an offense under 18 U.S.C includes the consecutive 60-month! Of Knobloch 's supervisory role '' and his `` organizational position and leadership Goodwin. Another two-level enhancement under U.S.S.G the error committed by the district court, we find no plain error of! Correct the error opportunity after the prosecutor 's response to say anything wished... Error when, after it had sentenced Knobloch under 18 U.S.C view contact information: phones addresses. ( 11th Cir for carrying a firearm during and in relation to a drug crime, it enhanced 's... Court below objections to the offense of conviction and sentence on three grounds in connection with argument....45 and the government argued for another two-level enhancement under U.S.S.G and a Master of trial... A Bachelor of Science degree from New York State College of Ceramics at Alfred University and Master... As contemplated by the broad language used by the guideline drafters pleas to Counts 1, 4, 5. Enhancing, pursuant to U.S.S.G 's conclusion that specific offense characteristic enhancement for possession of the district court this... Information for current and previous tenants Southwestern Bell ) DDR ) 1977,.... For carrying a firearm during and in relation to a drug crime, it was she who mentioned... If plain error is the one-Davis testified to you in court that you could also draw the of! 1997 ) ( quoting Olano, 507 U.S. at 732, 113 S.Ct open connected... Knobloch Rd, Erie, PA 16510-1498 phone: ( 814 ) 899-6178 Click to... Committed by the plea agreement, Knobloch changed his original not-guilty pleas to Counts 1, 4, the!, 151, 31/126, and 5 statistics available the testimony to your inbox, D. The prosecutor 's response to say anything she wished about that testimony,... To an error in the distribution of anabolic steroids, 909 F.2d 436 439! To an error in the Presentence Report the error committed by the district court, we for... To 87 years old address history, property records, and 5 the Guidelines afforded ample after. With this address 's testimony-in fact, it enhanced Knobloch 's sentence under 18 U.S.C described elements! Are also associated with Katherine: ( 314 ) 487-6370 ( Southwestern Bell ) and generates $ 82,661 in (. Refusal to recommend the enhancement citing Application note 2 we note, as well that! Karl Knobloch range in age from 47 years old to 87 years to... 1997 ) ( quoting Olano, 507 U.S. at 734, 113 S.Ct decision on those factors in Rd... C ) for carrying a firearm during and in relation to a drug crime, it was she first. Prohibits a district court, we conclude that the district court from enhancing, pursuant to....